
November 19, 2026
11/19/2026 | 55m 20sVideo has Closed Captions
Rush Doshi; Ronen Bergman; Volker Türk; Ayanna Howard
Rush Doshi, former NSC official, discusses Trump's summit with China and Russia. New York Times reporter Ronen Bergman examines the threat of renewed U.S. strikes on Iran. Volker Türk, U.N. human rights chief, discusses Myanmar's genocide ruling and global human rights. Ayanna Howard, president of Spelman College and author of Rebooting the Machines, discusses the ethics and morality of AI.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback

November 19, 2026
11/19/2026 | 55m 20sVideo has Closed Captions
Rush Doshi, former NSC official, discusses Trump's summit with China and Russia. New York Times reporter Ronen Bergman examines the threat of renewed U.S. strikes on Iran. Volker Türk, U.N. human rights chief, discusses Myanmar's genocide ruling and global human rights. Ayanna Howard, president of Spelman College and author of Rebooting the Machines, discusses the ethics and morality of AI.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Where to Watch Amanpour and Company
Amanpour and Company is available to stream on pbs.org and the PBS app.

Watch Amanpour and Company on PBS
PBS and WNET, in collaboration with CNN, launched Amanpour and Company in September 2018. The series features wide-ranging, in-depth conversations with global thought leaders and cultural influencers on issues impacting the world each day, from politics, business, technology and arts, to science and sports.Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorship>> HELLO, EVERYONE, AND WELCOME TO "AMANPOUR & CO. "
HERE'S WHAT'S COMING UP.
>> TOO OFTEN PAST LEADERS AVOIDED TALKING TO NATIONS WITH WHOM THEY HAD DISAGREEMENTS, AND WE FEEL THE OPPOSITE.
>> A HISTORIC MEETING OF LEADERS OF THE WORLD'S BIGGEST NUCLEAR POWERS.
IS THIS THE NEW WORLD ORDER, OR JUST A PHOTO OP?
I ASKED BIDEN'S FORMER CHINA ADVISER RUSH DOSHI.
> >> THEN REPORTS SAY TRUMP IS CONSIDERING ANOTHER ROUND OF EXTENSIVE ATTACKS ON IRAN UNDER IMMENSE PRESSURE FROM ISRAEL.
WE GET THE DETAILS FROM "NEW YORK TIMES" JOURNALIST RONEN BERGMAN.
> >> PLUS -- >> THE REPUBLIC OF THE REALM OF MYANMAR HAS COMMITTED GENOCIDE AGAINST THE ROHINGYA GROUP.
>> A LANDMARK RULING AT THE INTERNATIONAL COURT OF JUSTICE AS MYANMAR BECOMES THE FIRST STATE EVER FOUND GUILTY OF COMMITTING GENOCIDE.
I SPEAK TO THE U. N.
'S HIGH COMMISSIONER FOR HUMAN RIGHTS ABOUT THE REPERCUSSIONS FOR A CONFLICT- RIDDLED WORLD.
> >> ALSO AHEAD -- >> WHEN YOU'RE DEPLOYING A DRUG, IF YOU HAVE ANY OTHER FINDINGS IF SOMETHING HAPPENS, ONE, YOU TO REPORT IT, BUT SOMETIMES YOU ALSO TAKE IT OFF THE MARKET.
IMAGINE AI WORKED THE SAME.
>> "REBOOTING THE MACHINES. "
THE PRESIDENT OF SPELMAN COLLEGE AND RENOWNED ROBOTIST AYANNA HOWARD INTRODUCES HER BOOK, A GUIDE TO RETHINKING OUR RELATIONSHIP WITH ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE.
?
?
> >> "AMANPOUR & CO. "
IS MADE POSSIBLE BY -- THE ANDERSON FAMILY ENDOWMENT JIM ATTWOOD AND LESLIE WILLIAMS CANDACE KING WEIR CHARLES ROSENBLUM NORMA C. WARNER AND PAUL D. WARNER MONIQUE SCHOEN WARSHAW THE SYLVIA A. AND SIMON B. POYTA PROGRAMING ENDOWMENT TO FIGHT ANTISEMITISM THE STRAUS FAMILY FOUNDATION THE PETER G. PETERSON AND JOAN GANZ COONEY FUND KOO AND PATRICIA YUEN, COMMITTED TO BRIDGING CULTURAL DIFFERENCES IN OUR COMMUNITIES BARBARA HOPE ZUCKERBERG AND BY CONTRIBUTIONS TO YOUR PBS STATION FROM VIEWERS LIKE YOU.
THANK YOU.
> >> WELCOME TO THE PROGRAM, EVERYONE.
I'M CHRISTIANE AMANPOUR IN LONDON.
FOR DECADES, THE SO-CALLED LIBERAL WORLD ORDER WAS SHAPED BY AMERICA AND ITS DEMOCRATIC ALLIES, BUT PRESIDENT TRUMP'S UNPRECEDENTED SUMMIT WITH HIS CHINESE AND RUSSIAN COUNTERPARTS HAS SENT A CLEAR MESSAGE THAT HE IS READY TO CHANGE THAT.
PRESIDENT PUTIN AND PRESIDENT XI HAVE BEEN BROUGHT IN FROM THE COLD, AND NOW IT'S EUROPE THAT WORRIES FROM THE SIDELINES AS ADVERSARIES WIN GREATER FAVOR WITH TRUMP.
TAKE A LISTEN.
>> PRESIDENT XI AND I HAVE FORMED AN OUTSTANDING PERSONAL RELATIONSHIP.
IT REALLY IS.
SOME PEOPLE ARE UNHAPPY WHEN THEY HEAR THAT, BUT I'M VERY HAPPY ABOUT IT.
>> WHO IS HE?
HE'S MY FRIEND.
>> NOW THE POLISH PRIME MINISTER'S RESPONSE, "GOD PROTECT US FROM SUCH FRIENDS," REFERRING TO PUTIN, OF COURSE.
PUTIN, SUPPORTED BY CHINA, HAS MADE NO MOVES TOWARDS PEACE IN UKRAINE, AT THIS MOMENT ANY WAY.
IT'S UNCLEAR WHETHER EITHER PROMISED TRUMP THAT THEY WOULD STOP HELPING IRAN, BUT THEY HAVE ALL ISSUED A JOINT DECLARATION OF PEACE.
IN IT, THEY AGREE ON NUCLEAR RISK REDUCTION, UNITED NATIONS REFORM, AND UPHOLDING THE IMPUNITY OF STATE OFFICIALS IN INTERNATIONAL COURTS.
NOW RUSH DOSHI SERVED AS A TOP CHINA ADVISER ON PRESIDENT BIDEN'S NATIONAL SECURITY COUNCIL.
HE IS NOW A PROFESSOR OF SECURITY STUDIES AT GEORGETOWN UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF FOREIGN SERVICE, AND HE IS JOINING ME FROM WASHINGTON.
WELCOME BACK TO THE PROGRAM.
RUSH DOSHI, I NEED TO ASK YOU FIRST, REALLY, MORE CONTEXT, BECAUSE AS WE WERE GETTING READY TO COME ON AIR, WE SAW THE LIVE PRESS CONFERENCE IN BERLIN, WHICH WAS PRESIDENT TRUMP'S ADVISERS AND ENVOY S JARED KUSHNER AND STEVE WITKOFF WITH PRESIDENT ZELENSKYY AND ALL THE EUROPEAN ALLIES GIVING THEIR VERBAL COMMITMENT TO SUPPORTING UKRAINE AND BRINGING EUROPE ABSOLUTELY INTO ANY SORT OF PEACE OR SECURITY NEGOTIATIONS.
SO TELL ME HOW YOU READ THAT IN BERLIN AND THAT IN CHINA BETWEEN TRUMP, XI, AND PUTIN.
>> WELL, THANK YOU SO MUCH.
IT'S GREAT TO BE WITH YOU.
I THINK WHAT WE SAW IN BERLIN WAS AN EFFORT TO BALANCE A LITTLE BIT OF WHAT WE JUST SAW IN SHENZHEN.
I MEAN, THE MEETING BETWEEN THESE THREE WORLD LEADERS, TRUMP, PUTIN AND XI IS UNPRECEDENTED.
AND REMEMBER THE OPTIC TAOS WITH PRESIDENT XI AT THE CENTER OF THAT ROOM, AT THE CENTER OF THAT TABLE, FLANKED BY THE LEADERS OF RUSSIA, RIGHT AT THE RIGHT-HAND SIDE IN THE PRIME POSITION, AND DONALD TRUMP AT THE LEFT-HAND SIDE.
SO I DO THINK IT CREATES A LITTLE BIT OF BALANCE BETWEEN THE OPTICS OF THOSE TWO ENGAGEMENTS.
BUT IN REALITY I THINK PEOPLE WILL LOOK AT WHAT HAPPENED IN SHENZHEN WITH GREAT CONCERN.
>> WELL, WHAT DID HAPPEN IN SHENZHEN?
YOU MENTIONED, YOU KNOW, THE CENTER, THE LEFT, THE RIGHT.
I TALKED TO MATT POTTINGER, WHO HAS YOU KNOW WELL WAS PRESIDENT TRUMP'S DEPUTY NATIONAL SECURITY ADVISER DURING HIS FIRST TERM.
LAST NIGHT HE SAID THIS TRILATERAL SUMMIT IS TRUMP'S SHOW, BUT THE SCRIPT IS VLADIMIR PUTIN'S AND XI JINPING'S.
DO YOU AGREE TO THAT?
>> YEAH, I THINK THAT SOUNDS ABOUT RIGHT.
BUT I THINK THE SCRIPT IS REALLY ESPECIALLY PRESIDENT XI'S.
THE MAIN TAKEAWAY FROM THAT SUMMIT, BESIDES THE KIND OF PRESS RELEASE THEY ISSUED AT THE END IS THAT CHINA SAT THE CENTER.
CHINA IS THE CONVENER.
CHINA IS PERHAPS THE KEY PLAYER.
AND, AGAIN, PRESIDENT TRUMP NOT EXACTLY IN A PRIME POSITION.
I DO THINK ALSO IF YOU LOOK AT WHAT THEY AGREED ON, A LOT OF IT WAS PARTICULARLY UNINTERESTING OR UNIMPORTANT.
ON NUCLEAR WEAPONS, THAT WAS PRESIDENT TRUMP'S PRIORITY.
WE GOT NOTHING NEW OTHER THAN WE SHOULDN'T FIGHT NUCLEAR WARS WHICH ALL GREAT POWERS HAVE SAID MANY, MANY TIMES BEFORE.
SO I THINK THE OPTICS MATTER MORE THAN THE SUBSTANCE, BECAUSE THE OPTICS SEND A SIGNAL TO AMERICAN ALLIES AND PARTNERS THAT PERHAPS GREAT POWER DIPLOMACY COMES AHEAD OF ALLIED AND PARTNER DIPLOMACY.
I WOULD JUST ADD TO THAT THE SUMMIT WE SAW BETWEEN THESE THREE LEADERS WAS TWICE AS LONG AS PRESIDENT TRUMP'S SUMMIT WITH THE QUAD, WHICH IS WITH THE U. S. , JAPAN, AUSTRALIA, AND INDIA.
AND THAT ITSELF IS AN INDICATION, I THINK, OF WHERE HIS PRIORITIES LIE.
>> SO, THEN, FOR THE PRAGMATICS, WHERE DOES ONE HEAD FROM THIS SUMMIT THEN?
AND AS YOU SAY, THE SORT OF BALANCING MOMENT IN BERLIN.
LET'S FACE IT.
PRESIDENT TRUMP, THE LEADER OF THE FREE WORLD, IS MEETING WITH TWO ESSENTIALLY ADVERSARIES, ALTHOUGH THEY ALL PUT ON A GREAT CHUMMY-CHUMMY SHOW TOGETHER AND TRUMP CALLED PUTIN HIS FRIEND.
BUT PUTIN IS SUPPORTING IRAN.
PUTIN SAT WAR WITH THE WEST ALLY UKRAINE.
CHINA IS SUPPORTING RUSSIA IN THAT BATTLE, AND BOTH, AS I SAID CHINA AS WELL IS HELPING IRAN.
DO YOU THINK TRUMP GOT ANY JOY ON TRYING TO GET THEM TO AT LEAST STOP HELPING IRAN?
>> IT DOES NOT LOOK LIKE HE MADE ANY SUBSTANTIVE PROGRESS ON ANY PRIORITIES AT ALL IN THOSE MEETINGS.
I THINK THE MEETINGS WERE ENTIRELY A PHOTO OP.
AND ONE OF THE INDICATIONS OF THAT IS THAT WE DON'T SEE ANYTHING IN THE READOUTS ABOUT IRAN OR ABOUT UKRAINE IN ANY OF THE MEETINGS HE HAD WITH THESE TWO LEADERS, WHETHER THE TRILATERALS HE HAD OR THE BILATERAL HE HAD WITH CHINA AND WITH RUSSIA.
SO THE FACT THAT IT'S NOT IN THE READOUTS IS QUITE TELLING.
THE ONLY THING THAT IS IN READOUT OF THE TRILATERAL IS AGAIN ABOUT THE INTERNATIONAL CRIMINAL COURT, BUT SOME MODEST REFORMS TO THE U. N. , ABOUT ENERGY FLOWS AND NOT FIGHTING NUCLEAR WARS.
BUT CONSPICUOUSLY ABSENT IS THE HARD ISSUES, AGAIN, IRAN AND UKRAINE.
WITH CHINA, THAT BILATERAL MEETING TOO, WE DON'T SEE MUCH OUT OF IT ON THE ISSUES THAT MATTER --CHIP CONTROL, ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE, OR THE SUPPLY OF RARE EARTHS TO THE UNITED STATES.
SO THE HARD ISSUES GOT SHELVED.
THE PHOTO OP WAS THE PRIORITY AND I THINK THE ALLIES GOT THE SHORT END OF THE BARGAIN.
>> IT WAS SAID AT THE BERLIN PRESSER THAT PRESIDENT TRUMP CALLED INTO THE MEETING, THE ALLIES MEETING, AND OF COURSE ZELENSKYY WOULD HAVE BEEN THERE.
UNCLEAR TOTALLY WHAT WAS SAID THERE, BUT THERE WAS A BIT OF A --FROM JARED KUSHNER ON THAT CALL-IN.
PRESUMABLY WILL HE GIVE MORE WHEN HE GIVES A PRESS CONFERENCE ON FRIDAY.
LET ME ASK ABOUT THIS QUITE UNUSUAL CLAUSE THAT STATE LEADERS SHOULD BE, YOU KNOW, HAVE IMPUNITY AND IMMUNITY WHEN IT COMES TO INTERNATIONAL CRIMINAL COURTS.
THIS IS WHAT PRESIDENT TRUMP SAID ABOUT THAT ISSUE.
I'M GOING PLAY THE SOUND BITE.
.
>> IN ANOTHER AREA OF POTENTIAL COOPERATION BETWEEN US, I'LL BE SUGGESTING WAYS TO PROTECT OUR NATION'S SOVEREIGNTY FROM ROGUE GLOBALIST ORGANIZATIONS SUCH AS THE INTERNATIONAL CRIMINAL COURT WHICH HAS GOTTEN OUT OF CONTROL, WHICH I BELIEVE WE ALL AGREE HAS REALLY STRAYED FAR FROM BEYOND ITS JURISDICTION.
>> WELL, IT'S A BIG YIKES MOMENT THERE.
I MEAN, CLEARLY WE KNOW THAT THE TRUMP ADMINISTRATION, BECAUSE THEY'VE SAID IT, WANT TO DISMANTLE THE ICC BRICK BY BRICK.
BUT WE ALSO KNOW THAT PUTIN HAS BEEN INDICTED BY THAT SAME TRIBUNAL FOR CRIMES COMMITTED BY HIS FORCES AND HIS ADMINISTRATION IN UKRAINE.
WHY DO YOU THINK THAT WAS SUCH A BIG DEAL AT A SUMMIT OF THE THREE MAJOR NUCLEAR POWERS?
>> WELL, I THINK WHAT YOU'RE SEEING IS THE GREAT POWER, AT LEAST IN THIS INCARNATION, WANT TO CARVE UP SOME OF THE INTERNATIONAL INSTITUTIONS THAT THEY DISAGREE WITH.
AND THEY CAN ALIGN ON THE FACT THAT THEY DON'T WANT THEIR STATES TO BE BOUND BY THOSE INSTITUTIONS.
INTERNATIONAL CRIMINAL COURT IN PARTICULAR HAS COME UNDER CRITICISM FROM ALL THREE, AND IT PROBABLY IS AN AREA WHERE THEY CAN AGREE.
OF COURSE, IT DISPROPORTIONATELY BENEFITS VLADIMIR PUTIN GIVEN THAT HE IS DIRECTLY IMPLICATED BY THE COURT IN A VARIETY OF ATROCITIES.
SO AS A RESULT, THIS IS ONE OF THE AREAS WHERE THE TWO SIDES, THE U. S. AND RUSSIA, ALONG WITH CHINA CAN GET TOGETHER AND FIND COMMON CAUSE.
I THINK THE OTHER SENSE HERE WHEN GREAT POWERS GET TOGETHER LIKE THIS IS THEY MIGHT TRY TO BE CARVING UP THE WORLD.
I'M NOT SURE THAT'S EXACTLY WHAT HAPPENED IN THIS MEETING, BUT THE IMAGE IS UNMISTAKABLE.
>> YEAH.
I'M STAYING AWAY FROM THE TERM "YALTA".
>> YES.
>> I THINK PROBABLY BEEN OVERUSED AND I THINK YOU JUST INDICATED THERE IS NO INDICATION OF THAT.
BUT I WANT TO KNOW ALSO, OF COURSE, THIS ICC COMMENT FROM THEM COMES ON THE DAY THAT A STATE FOR THE VERY FIRST TIME HAS BEEN CONVICTED OF COMMITTING GENOCIDE.
THAT'S MYANMAR, THE STATE, AND THE MILITARY JUNTA THERE AGAINST THE ROHINGYA MINORITY, THE MUSLIM MINORITY, WHICH I THINK IS NOT NECESSARILY A COINCIDENCE.
I WANT TO ASK YOU THIS, BECAUSE ALL OF, THIS AND THEY'RE TALKING ABOUT TRYING TO WORK FOR GLOBAL PEACE, PUTIN, OF COURSE, HAS DECIDED THERE WILL BE NO NEGOTIATIONS WITH UKRAINE IN HIS WORDS BECAUSE OF WHAT THEY DID WITH THE KERCH BRIDGE, BLOWING A HOLE IN IT, WHICH IS THE SUPPLY ROUTE TO CRIMEA.
NO NEGOTIATIONS RIGHT NOW.
AND WE KNOW THAT HE IS BLASTING AWAY AT ALL UKRAINE'S MASSIVE ENERGY INFRASTRUCTURE, TRYING TO BREAK THEIR WILL.
AGAIN, THIS WINTER.
BUT ALSO, THERE IS OTHER WAR DRUMS BEING BEATEN, AND THAT IS, AGAIN REGARDING IRAN.
YOU MUST HAVE BEEN SEEING THE INCREASING REPORTS COMING OUT SAYING IRAN'S GOT A DIRTY BOMB PLAN AND ISSUE IS TRYING TO FORCE TRUMP TO ENGAGE AGAIN IN A SHORT BUT HARD STRIKE.
THE WHOLE IDEA OF ANNIHILATING A CIVILIZATION IS COMING UP AGAIN.
WHERE DO YOU THINK THAT'S GOING TO LEAD?
WHAT DO YOU THINK OF THE POLITICS AND THE POLICIES LEADING IN THIS DIRECTION?
>> WELL, WHAT'S INTERESTING IS THERE IS OBVIOUSLY CAUSE FOR CHINA, RUSSIA, AND THE UNITED STATES TO DISCUSS EXACTLY WHAT YOU MENTIONED, WHICH IS THE POSSIBILITY OF GREATER ESCALATION, FURTHER INSTABILITY GIVEN THE CRISIS IN THE GULF AND THE WAR WITH IRAN.
AND IN ACTUALITY, THERE DOESN'T LOOK LIKE THERE WAS ANY PROGRESS ON THOSE ISSUES.
IF THE SITUATION IS POTENTIALLY IS AS SERIOUS AS SOME ARE SUGGESTING, YOU WOULD THINK CHINA WOULD FIND A WAY TO HELP WIND THE CONFLICT DOWN AND RUSSIA MIGHT THINK ABOUT REDUCING SUPPORT FOR IRAN.
BUT REALITY IS BOTH THESE COUNTRIES THINK THEY BENEFIT FROM THE U. S. INVOLVEMENT IN IRAN.
CHINA THINKS IT BUYS MORE STRATEGIC SPACE.
IT ALSO DISTRACTS THE UNITED STATES FROM EVEN THINKING ABOUT CHINA WHILE IT BLOWS ITS MUNITIONS IN ANOTHER POINTLESS WAR IN THE MIDDLE EAST.
AND RUSSIA FOR ITS PART MIGHT BE ABLE TO KEEP ENERGY PRICES HIGHER AND KEEP THE UNITED STATES BOGGED DOWN.
ALL THIS MEANS EVEN THOUGH THESE GREAT POWERS GOT TOGETHER AND TALKED A GOOD GAME ABOUT PEACE, THEIR INTERESTS, AS YOU NOTED EARLIER, ARE DIVERGENT ON THESE CORE QUESTIONS.
CHINA IS RUSSIA'S PRINCIPLE BACKER IN UKRAINE AND IN THE MIDDLE EAST.
>> WE'RE GOING PURSUE THE IRAN WAR DRUMS ARE BANGING AGAIN.
THE "NEW YORK TIMES" REPORTS THE UNITED STATES IS CONSIDERING ANOTHER ROUND OF STRIKES UNDER GROWING PRESSURE FROM BENJAMIN NETANYAHU.
MEANWHILE, CNN HAS REPORTED U. S. INTELLIGENCE SUGGESTS IRAN MAY BE DEVELOPING PLANS TO DETONATE A DIRTY BOMB IN WASHINGTON.
NOW ASKED THAN REPORT, TRUMP DOWNPLAYED THE THREAT BUT DID SAY IRAN WAS LOOKING AT BIOLOGICAL WEAPONS.
SECRETARY OF STATE MARCO RUBIO STRESSED HE DOES NOT BELIEVE THERE IS AN IMMINENT THREAT TO THE U. S. CAPITOL.
SO WHERE IS ALL THIS INTEL COMING FROM?
LET'S ASK STAFF WRITER FOR "THE NEW YORK TIMES" RONEN BERGMAN WHO IS JOINING ME NOW FROM TEL AVIV.
RONEN, WELCOME BACK TO THE PROGRAM.
YOU HAVE WRITTEN YET ANOTHER DEEPLY RESEARCHED AND INVESTIGATED ARTICLE ABOUT THIS CURRENT ISSUE.
SO FROM WHERE YOU'RE SITTING IN ISRAEL, HOW LIKELY IS IT?
WHO ARE PURSUING THIS KIND OF INTELLIGENCE, SPREADING THIS KIND OF INTELLIGENCE?
WHAT'S GOING ON?
>> SO I THINK THAT TWO PHASES TO LOOK AT.
AND TO BE HERE AGAIN, THANKS FOR THE INVITE.
THE TIME UNTIL THE ELECTIONS IN ISRAEL, OCTOBER 27th IS TIMES WHEN BENJAMIN NETANYAHU SORT OF HOPE ON AMERICA REQUEST TO BE READY FOR POTENTIAL JOINT STRIKE, YET THEY ARE FAR AWAY FROM READY.
HE WANTED TO ACCELERATE THE PREPARATIONS.
HE WANTED TO ATTACK BEFORE THE ELECTIONS.
AND THE MILITARY PERSONNEL -- IS TRYING TO DISRUPT THE CONDUCT OF THE ELECTIONS.
AND THEY STOOD QUITE FIRM AND OBJECTED THAT.
WHAT HAPPENED AFTER THE ELECTION IN ISRAEL IS DIFFERENT.
AND IN THAT SENSE, I THINK THERE IS A SORT OF A UNANIMOUS VOTE INSIDE ISRAELI INTELLIGENCE AND SECURITY ESTABLISHMENT THAT IF THE U. S. AND ISRAEL -- NOT NECESSARILY NOW, BUT IF THE U. S. AND ISRAEL WOULD GO TOGETHER, THEY BELIEVE THAT THEY CAN GET, FIRST OF ALL, ELIMINATE SOME THREATS THAT THEY BELIEVE WERE ACCELERATED, INFLATED IN THE LAST FEW MONTHS, MAINLY ON THE PRODUCTION AND EXERCISES AND TESTING OF CHEMICAL WEAPON, AND THEY BELIEVE THAT THEY CAN MAYBE STOP THE DEADLOCK IN THE GULF.
BENJAMIN NETANYAHU, FROM HIS POINT OF VIEW, IS OF COURSE ACCELERATING THIS, PUSHING THIS, SENDING HIS LIEUTENANT GENERALS TO WASHINGTON TO TRY TO CONVINCE THE U. S. GOVERNMENT THAT THIS IS A RELIABLE THREAT.
IRAN IS PRODUCING GAS, CHEMICAL WEAPON IN ORDER TO ARM DRONE AND MAYBE HARM AMERICAN POLITICIANS.
CREATE A FEAR, A LEGENDARY FEAR THAT MIGHT CONVINCE, AGAIN, THE AMERICA ADMINISTRATION TO GO FOR A JOINT STRIKE WITH ISRAELI-AMERICAN STRIKE AND HITTING IRAN.
>> RONEN, WHAT DO YOUR -- WHAT DO YOUR SOURCES SAY ABOUT THAT INTEL?
IS IT CREDIBLE, YOUR ACTUAL SOURCES WHO KNOW THE LAY OF THE LAND?
BECAUSE, YOU KNOW, IT KIND OF REMINDS ME OF THE FAULTY INTEL BEHIND THE IRAQ WAR.
>> YEAH.
WELL, I THINK EVEN AT A MORE IMMEDIATE EXAMPLE, AND THIS IS THE INTELLIGENCE THAT LED ISRAELI INTELLIGENCE, PART OF ISRAELI INTELLIGENCE, PART OF MOSSAD, JUST BEFORE THE ATTACK THIS YEAR FEBRUARY 28th TO BELIEVE AND SUGGEST AND LOBBY AND PITCH TO THE AMERICAN A SIGN THAT THEY ARE ABLE TO HAVE ENOUGH INTELLIGENCE, ENOUGH UNDERSTANDING, ENOUGH INFILTRATION THAT THEY ARE ABLE TO TOPPLE THE REGIME IN A COUNTRY OF 19 MILLION PEOPLE THE SIZE OF WESTERN EUROPE.
SO I THINK THERE IS A LOT OF MISBELIEF IN THE U. S. SIDE.
I THINK ISRAEL, OR THE ISRAELI SOURCES I'M SPEAKING WITH, THEY SAY IS IS NOT AN IMMEDIATE THREAT THERE IS A THREAT.
OF COURSE, THEY LOOK AT THE BIGGER PICTURE AND THAT IS NOTHING IS MOVING IN THE GULF.
IRAN IS STILL HAVING ENRICHED URANIUM THAT CAN CREATE 11.
5 NUCLEAR BOMBS.
AND IT SEEMS THAT THE CHANCE THAT THE U. S. AGAIN WILL JOIN IS SORT OF ALLURING ENOUGH FOR ISRAELI OFFICIALS.
WHILE THEY ADMIT IN PRIVATE CONVERSATION THAT THERE IS NOTHING URGENT THAT FORCE ISRAEL OR THE U. S. OR SHOULD FORCE THEM TO ATTACK NOW.
FROM BENJAMIN NETANYAHU POINT OF VIEW, THE CLOCK IS TICKING.
HE MIGHT BE FACING A NEW GOVERNMENT.
>> YEAH.
>> AN INABILITY TO LAUNCH AN ATTACK.
AND I THINK THE SAME WITH PRESIDENT TRUMP.
>> SO THAT'S INTERESTING, BECAUSE TWO POINTS TO COME OUT OF THAT, THEN.
WHAT ARE YOU HEARING ABOUT HOW IT'S PLAYING AROUND THE ATTEMPT TO FORM A COALITION?
AND IS THERE ANY PROGRESS IN TRYING TO FORM A COALITION?
>> SO FIRST OF ALL, JUST DAYS BEFORE THE ELECTIONS, SOME LEADERS OF THE OPPOSITION WERE NOTIFIED THAT BENJAMIN NETANYAHU IS PUSHING FOR A STRIKE SHORT OF AN AVERT AERIAL ATTACK, MEANING SOMETHING THAT WOULD BE COVERT BUT WOULD THUNDEROUS END, MEANING SOMEONE KILLED OR SOME FACILITIES SABOTAGED IN IRAN, WOULD FORCE IRAN TO RETALIATE.
AND ACCORDING TO BENJAMIN NETANYAHU PLAN, THIS IS WHAT WE HEAR FROM MULTIPLE SOURCES NOW, BECOME A REALITY.
HE'S ASPIRING FOR WAR IN ORDER TO CREATE A SITUATION OF EMERGENCY, OF COURSE WAR WITH IRAN IS A SITUATION OF EMERGENCY.
AND THEN FORCE A UNITY GOVERNMENT ON THE OPPOSITION THAT ALREADY SWORE THAT THEY DON'T WANT ANYONE FROM THE GOVERNMENT AND ANYTHING WITH NETANYAHU IN THE NEW COALITION.
BUT UNDER THE CONDITIONS OF WAR WITH DOMESTIC PRESSURE, WITH AMERICAN PRESSURE, BENJAMIN NETANYAHU BELIEVES OR HOPE THAT THIS WILL LEAD HIM TO A GOVERNMENT THAT WILL INCLUDE HIM.
HE'S DOING EVERYTHING HE CAN AND THEN SOME, VIOLATING THE LAW, CALLING THE ARABS -- THE ARAB PARTIES, THE ARAB VOTERS ILLEGITIMATE, INVENTING STORIES ABOUT FORGERY.
WELL, HE IS THE ONLY ONE WHO IS TRYING TO STEAL THE ELECTIONS.
HE IS DOING EVERYTHING HE CAN TO REMAIN IN POWER.
AND THIS IS --IF THERE ARE REAL THREATS, IF THERE IS A REAL THREATEN, REAL IMMINENT THREAT TO SURVIVAL OF ISRAEL, I WOULD SAY THIS IS THE THREAT AND NOT SOMETHING THAT MAY OR MAY NOT HAPPEN OR BE HAPPENING IN IRAN.
>> AND LAST QUESTION.
PRESIDENT TRUMP DID ACTUALLY TALK ABOUT WHAT MIGHT HAPPEN, AND HE SAID THAT THE U. S. WOULD SEE WHAT HAPPENS WITH IRAN AFTER JANUARY 1st.
KIND OF UNCLEAR WHAT THAT MEANS.
BUT THEY'VE ALSO I THINK YOU'VE BEEN REPORTING THAT IF THERE WAS TO BE ANY JOINT U. S.
-ISRAELI BOMBING, IT WAS GOING TO GO BACK TO THAT MAXIMALIST THREAT THEY MADE BEFORE THE MEMORANDUM OF UNDERSTANDING IN THE SPRING WHEN THEY TALKED OF ANNIHILATING CIVILIZATION, ET CETERA.
WHAT DOES THAT MEAN MILITARILY, AND IS THAT WHAT THEY'RE LOOKING AT?
>> SO PART OF THE SO-CALLED PLAN TO TOPPLE THE REGIME WAS AN ONGOING MULTIFRONT PRESSURE THAT ISRAEL AND THE U. S. WERE SUPPOSED TO PUT ON IRAN.
AND ONE OF THEM WAS TO ERADICATE OR TO DAMAGE SIGNIFICANTLY THE ENERGY SECTOR AND THE ELECTRICITY NETWORK OF IRAN.
THAT PART DID NOT HAPPEN BECAUSE PRESIDENT TRUMP PREVENTED THAT.
ONE OF THE ADVISERS THE EXCUSES THAT ISRAEL, SOME PEOPLE FROM MOSSAD ARE USING IN ORDER TO SAY THIS IS WHY THEY DID NOT SUCCEED IN TOPPLING THE REGIME.
I THINK THERE WILL MANY OTHER REASONS WHY THEY DIDN'T, BUT LEAVE ASIDE.
PRESIDENT TRUMP THREATENED TO EXECUTE THAT PLAN JUST BEFORE SIGNING.
HE SAID ANNIHILATING IRANIAN CIVILIZATION.
FOR HIM I UNDERSTAND THE CIVILIZATION MEANS THE ENERGY SECTOR.
BUT THIS IS BACK ON THE TABLE.
ISRAEL BELIEVE THE REASON THEY DIDN'T SUCCEED SO FAR, THEY'RE LOOKING ON A ONE-YEAR WAR.
THEY THOUGHT IT WAS GOING TO LAST ONLY ONE WEEK, BUT SOME PEOPLE BELIEVE NETANYAHU'S IMMEDIATE VICINITY, HIS ENTOURAGE BELIEVE IT DIDN'T SUCCEED BECAUSE THEY DIDN'T EXERCISE ENOUGH FORCE.
IF THEY REINSTALL THAT PLAN, WHICH WILL TAKE IRAN BACKWARDS AND JUST BRING MORE MISERY TO THE AREA, THEY SUCCEED.
OF COURSE THERE ARE OTHER PEOPLE, MANY OTHER PEOPLE, INCLUDING IN THE AIR FORCE AND IN THE ARMED FORCES WHO SAY IT'S NOT THAT WE DID NOT EXERCISE ENOUGH FORCE.
WE JUST --THE WHOLE THING WAS JUST WRONG.
AND IF WE EXERCISE MORE FORCE, WE WILL JUST DIMINISH THE CHANCES THAT WE'LL HAVE ANY SENTIMENT WITH EUROPE.
>> REALLY, REALLY A CRITICAL MOMENT.
AND THIS WHOLE PROCESS OF WHAT YOU'RE DESCRIBING, DOUBLING DOWN, EVEN WHEN YOU'RE NOT ACTUALLY WINNING, PUTIN IS DOING THAT IN UKRAINE OR U. S. , ISRAEL WANTS TO DO THAT IN IRAN, IT'S A REALLY INTERESTING MOMENT.
THANKS FOR YOUR INVESTIGATIVE REPORTING, RONEN BERGMAN.
THANK YOU FOR JOINING US.
>> THANK YOU.
> >> NOW AS WE MENTIONED, FOR THE VERY FIRST TIME EVER, A STATE HAS BEEN FOUND GUILTY OF COMMITTING GENOCIDE BY AN INTERNATIONAL COURT.
AFTER THE ICJ RULED THAT MYANMAR HAS AIMED TO DESTROY A SUBSTANTIAL PART OF THE ROHINGYA MINORITY POPULATION.
SINCE THE 2017 MILITARY CRACKDOWN, THE GROUP HAS FACED PERSECUTION, SEEKING REFUGE IN NEIGHBORING BANGLADESH.
MYANMAR HAS PREVIOUSLY DENIED THESE ACCUSATIONS, AND FROM SUDAN TO GAZA TO PAKISTAN, SIMILAR OUTRAGES ARE HAPPENING IN MANY PARTS OF THE WORLD.
AS THE UNITED STATES TURNS AWAY FROM LEADING THE ENFORCEMENT OF INTERNATIONAL LAW AND HUMAN RIGHTS.
LET'S BRING IN U. N. HIGH COMMISSIONER FOR HUMAN RIGHT S VOLKER TURK WHO JOINS ME FROM GENEVA.
WELCOME TO THE PROGRAM.
I THINK IT'S A REALLY IMPORTANT TIME TO TAKE STOCK OF HUMAN RIGHTS AND HUMANITARIAN LAW.
FIRST AND FOREMOST, THIS IS QUITE A BIG DEAL, THE ACTUAL DECLARATION, THE PRONOUNCEMENT IN COURT THAT A STATE IS GUILTY OF GENOCIDE.
WHAT DO YOU THINK IT MEANS?
>> IT'S A HISTORIC JUDGMENT, BOTH IN ITS SCALE AND IN ITS SWEEP, INCREDIBLY IMPORTANT FOR THE VICTIMS, FOR THE SURVIVORS OF GENOCIDE, AND I ACTUALLY ALSO THINK OF ALL THE ROHINGYA I HAVE MET OVER MANY YEARS WHO I'M SURE ARE NOW CELEBRATING ABOUT BRINGING JUSTICE TO THEM.
ONE THING THAT I FIND ALSO PARTICULARLY STRIKING WITH THE JUDGMENT IS THAT IT NOT ONLY LOOKED AT KILLINGS, IT ALSO LOOKED AT DECADES OF DISCRIMINATION AND MARGINALIZATION OF THE ROHINGYA.
AND I MYSELF I REMEMBER.
I REMEMBER MEETING IN NORTHERN RAKAN STATE AN OLD LADY WHO SHOWED ME HER PINK CITIZENSHIP CERTIFICATE THAT WAS NO LONGER VALID.
AND THAT HAS BEEN IN PREPARATION FOR YEARS, THIS SYSTEMATIC DISCRIMINATION, THE FORCED DISPLACEMENT THAT THEY HAVE GONE THROUGH TIME AND TIME AGAIN.
SO NOW IT'S -- AND IT ALSO VALIDATED WHAT WE WITHIN THE UNITED NATIONS HAVE BEEN DOING FOR YEARS, OUR INVESTIGATIVE PARTIES DOCUMENTING THESE HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATIONS.
THE JUDGMENT REFERRED TO THEM IN A VERY SIGNIFICANT WAY.
SO I HOPE THAT ACTION WILL FOLLOW, BECAUSE THAT'S WHAT THE VICTIMS, WHAT THE ROHINGYA THEMSELVES ARE ASKING FOR URGENTLY.
>> SO WHAT --WHAT ACTION DO YOU THINK SHOULD FOLLOW UNDER INTERNATIONAL LAW?
THE PICTURES WE WERE SHOWING JUST THEN WERE THE HUNDREDS OF THOUSANDS OF ROHINGYA WHO HAVE BEEN FLEEING.
THAT WAS IN 2017.
AND THEY'RE THERE ON THE WATER, ON LAND IN BANGLADESH.
BECAUSE PRESIDENT TRUMP TODAY SAID THAT BASICALLY THE WORLD HAS TO BE PROTECTED FROM WHAT HE CALLED "ROGUE ORGANIZATIONS, GLOBALIST ORGANIZATIONS. "
AND YOU SAW THAT THE READOUT FROM THE SUMMIT WAS TO ENFORCE THE IMPUNITY AND THE IMMUNITY OF WORLD LEADERS FROM INTERNATIONAL COURTS.
>> SO WE NEED EXACTLY THE CONTRARY.
WHAT WE NEED IS ACCOUNTABILITY, INCLUDING INTERNATIONAL ACCOUNTABILITY.
I MYSELF CONTINUE TO ASK FOR THE WHOLE OF THE SITUATION OF MYANMAR TO BE REFERRED TO THE INTERNATIONAL CRIMINAL COURT.
THAT'S ONE ACTION THAT COULD BE TAKEN IMMEDIATELY.
THE OTHER ACTION IS WHEREVER --WHERE EVER THERE IS UNIVERSAL JURISDICTION THAT ACTUALLY THOSE CASES ARE BROUGHT TO JUSTICE.
WE HAVE SOME CASES NOW POPPING UP IN ARGENTINA, AND I HOPE THEY WILL BE BROUGHT TO JUSTICE.
THE OTHER THING IS NO MILITARY AID ANYMORE, NO JET FUEL, NO DUAL USE, AND REAL PRESSURE ON THE AUTHORITIES TO ENSURE THAT THE ROHINGYA ARE NOT ONLY COMPENSATED, BUT THEY ARE ACTUALLY GIVEN CITIZENSHIP.
THEY'RE NO LONGER DISCRIMINATED AGAINST AND THAT THERE IS A PROPER PATHWAY FOR THEM TO BE ABLE TO RETURN IN SAFETY AND IN DIGNITY AND VOLUNTARILY.
I THINK THAT'S EXTREMELY IMPORTANT.
OF COURSE WE ARE NOT THERE YET AT ALL.
BUT THAT'S WHAT THE INTERNATIONAL COMMUNITY NEEDS TO DEMAND NOW ON THE BASIS OF THIS JUDGMENT.
>> I WANT TO GO FROM A STATE TO AN INDIVIDUAL.
WE'VE SPOKEN ABOUT THIS BEFORE, THE CASE OF THE FORMER PRIME MINISTER OF PAKISTAN IMRAN KHAN, WHO HAS BEEN UNDER SOLITARY CONFINEMENT FOR MOST OF EVERY SINGLE DAY FOR THE LAST SEVERAL YEARS.
NOW, AS YOU KNOW, A U. N. BODY CALLED HIS TREATMENT INHUMANE.
HE SAID THAT IT AMOUNTS TO TORTURE, AND THAT, YOU KNOW, THAT HE'S VERY WORRIED ABOUT HIS OWN HEALTH.
HIS SISTERS HAVE BEEN SWEPT UP IN THESE ARRESTS, HIS WIFE AS WELL.
AS THE U. N. HUMAN RIGHTS HIGH COMMISSIONER, DO YOU NOT HAVE TO, YOU KNOW, SORT OF GO OUT THERE AND PUT HIS CASE OUT THERE AND LOBBY FOR ACTUAL HUMANE TREATMENT?
WHAT IS YOUR ROLE AND YOUR UNIT'S ROLE IN CASES LIKE THIS?
>> SO I HAVE MADE MANY -- MARCHES IN RELATION THOUGH THIS CASE, AND I ALSO DO IT PUBLICLY.
I CALL FOR HIS RELEASE.
I CALL FOR HIS PROPER TREATMENT, AND I ALSO CALL FOR DE-ESCALATION, BECAUSE WE NEED TO DIFFUSE THE POLITICAL TENSIONS THAT ARE AROUND THIS CASE, WHICH MEANS A CONFIDENCE-BUILDING MEASURE BETWEEN THE OPPOSITION AND THE GOVERNMENT COULD BE HIS IMMEDIATE RELEASE.
THAT'S WHAT WE HAVE BEEN ASKING, WHAT WE HAVE BEEN HOPING FOR.
AND I'M NOW DOING IT ALSO PUBLICLY.
>> YOU KNOW, THE PAKISTAN GOVERNMENT DENIES ANY OF HIS COMPLAINTS.
THEY SAY HE'S GOT, YOU KNOW, ADEQUATE CARE, BUT HE'S WRITTEN A LETTER TO THE HIGH COURT AND THE JUDGES URGING THEM TO ENFORCE THEIR OWN RULING THAT HE BE TREATED, THAT HE GET ACCESS TO HIS SONS, TO HIS LAWYERS, THAT HE BE ABLE TO SPEAK TO PEOPLE.
I MEAN, IT'S REALLY, REALLY EXTREME CONDITIONS.
IS THERE --IS THERE ANYTHING ELSE THAT YOU THINK THAT THE U. N. CAN DO TO ADVANCE THIS SITUATION?
>> FOR US, WE NEED TO CONTINUE ENGAGING WITH THE PAKISTANI AUTHORITIES.
AND AS I SAID, THEY NEED TO RESPECT THE INTERNATIONAL LEGAL STANDARDS WHEN IT COMES TO DETENTION.
THEY ALSO NEED --AND THERE IS A BROADER CONTEXT, I HAVE TO SAY, BECAUSE IT'S NOT JUST ONE VERY PROMINENT CASE.
WE ALSO HAVE ARBITRARY DETENTION OF HUMAN RIGHTS DEFENDERS, OF JOURNALIST, OF PEOPLE WHO ARE IN POLITICAL POSITION.
SO IT'S ABSOLUTELY CLEAR, AS I SAID, WE NEED DE-ESCALATION.
WE NEED A PROPER DIALOGUE, AND WE NEED TO RESPECT INTERNATIONAL LEGAL STANDARDS THAT APPLY TO PEOPLE WHO ARE MEDIA WORKERS, WHO ARE HUMAN RIGHTS DEFENDERS, OR WHO ARE IN THE POLITICAL OPPOSITION.
AND THE BEST WAY TO DO IT IS THROUGH CONFIDENCE BUILDING MEASURES, SUCH AS ALLOWING FAMILY VISITS, MAKING SURE THAT LAWYERS, THAT MEDICAL AID IS PROVIDED, AND THAT PEOPLE WHO SHOULD NEVER BE IN PRISON ARE RELEASED.
>> LET ME PUT OUT A LITTLE BIT TO SUDAN.
YOU HAVE BEEN, YOU KNOW, TRYING TO GET THE WORD OUT IN THIS FORGOTTEN WAR THAT THERE IS A MASSIVE WAR GOING ON, THAT THERE IS NO END IN SIGHT, THAT THE HUMANITARIAN SITUATION THERE IS REALLY DIRE, ONE OF THE WORST IN THE WORLD RIGHT NOW.
DESCRIBE FOR US WHO IS TO BLAME AND WHAT SHOULD BE DONE RIGHT NOW.
>> WHAT IS MOST IMPORTANT IS OBVIOUSLY THAT THERE IS A CEASEFIRE AGREEMENT AND THAT THERE IS PEACE.
I REMEMBER I MET --I WAS ONE OF THE FIRST COUNTRIES.
I VISITED IN 2022 WHEN I TOOK OVER AS HIGH COMMISSIONER FOR HUMAN RIGHTS BECAUSE I WANTED TO MEET THE YOUNG PEOPLE.
I WANTED TO MEET THE WOMEN WHO LED THE REVOLUTION AGAINST THE PREVIOUS MILITARY DICTATOR AL BASHIR.
AND I WAS REALLY ENCOURAGED BY WHAT I FELT WAS A PEOPLE'S REVOLUTION.
THEN THE MILITARY CAME BACK, AND WE SAW IN APRIL '23 THIS HORRIBLE WAR BROKE OUT WHICH WAS SUPPOSED TO LAST A COUPLE OF WEEKS.
NOW WE'RE INTO AN END OF '26.
THE COUNTRY HAS BEEN RAVAGED ANY WAR.
I MEAN, IT'S CLEAR THAT WE NEED NOT ONLY URGENT ACTION, THAT WE ALSO SEE THAT THIS WAR HAS DIRECTLY TO DO WITH US.
WE DID A VERY IMPORTANT REPORT ON GUM ARABIC, WHICH SHOWED THAT OUR CONSUMPTION PATTERNS, FOR INSTANCE, GUM ARABIC IS IN PHARMACEUTICAL PRODUCTS.
IT'S IN BEAUTY PRODUCTS.
IT'S IN OUR SWEETS, THAT THAT ACTUALLY HAS A LOT TO DO WITH GUM ARABIC THAT COMES FROM SUDAN THAT GETS BASICALLY SMUGGLED AND TRAFFICKED AND FUELS THE WAR ECONOMY.
THAT'S JUST ONE ASPECT OF IT.
SO WE ALSO NEED TO SEE THAT SUDAN IS NOT A FARAWAY CONFLICT, BUT IT HAS TO DO WITH OUR DAILY LIVES.
AND WE NEED TO PRESSURE BOTH PARTIES TO FIND AN AGREEMENT TO STOP THIS SENSELESS WAR THAT HAS REALLY RUINED THE COUNTRY IN ITS ENTIRETY.
>> LOOK, IT TAKES ALSO A LOT OF --A LOT OF INVOLVEMENT AND ENGAGEMENT FROM THE MOST POWERFUL COUNTRIES IN THE WORLD THAT ARE MEANT TO UPHOLD INTERNATIONAL LAW AND HUMAN RIGHTS.
SOME OF THE PARTIES FIGHTING IN OR INTERVENING IN SUDAN ARE VERY STRONG U. S. ALLIES, FOR INSTANCE.
AND I JUST WONDERED WHAT YOU THINK THE U. N. CAN DO WHEN YOU HAVE THE UNITED STATES BASICALLY REALLY NOT PRIORITIZING INTERNATIONAL RULE OF LAW OR HUMAN RIGHTS.
WE SAW THAT FROM THE PRESIDENT'S NOW CHIEF OF STAFF STEPHEN MILLER AFTER VENEZUELA.
HE SAID YEAH, INTERNATIONAL LAW ALL WELL AND GOOD, BUT IT'S NOT FOR US.
WE ARE THE STRONG POWER.
WE NEED TO DO WHAT WE HAVE TO DO.
SO WHEN YOU DON'T GET SUPPORT FROM THE U. S. , AS YOU HAVE HISTORICALLY, WHERE ELSE DO YOU GO TO TRY TO UPHOLD THE U. N. VALUES, AND PARTICULARLY IN YOUR DEPARTMENT?
>> I CAN TELL YOU ONE THING.
THE VAST MAJORITY OF PEOPLE CARE ABOUT HUMAN RIGHTS.
THEY CARE ABOUT HUMAN DIGNITY.
THEY STAND UP AGAINST CRUELTY.
WE HAVE ALSO SEEN THIS IN RECENT ELECTIONS WHERE INDEED SOME OF THOSE PRACTICES WERE PART OF THE ELECTORAL CAMPAIGNS.
AND I ALSO HAVE THE FEELING THAT MOST COUNTRIES CARE ABOUT INTERNATIONAL LAW.
I MEAN, OF COURSE THERE ARE THOSE WHO VIOLATE THE LAWS.
BUT THE VAST MAJORITY CARE ABOUT IT BECAUSE IT BRINGS THEM STABILITY.
IT DOESN'T ACCEPT MIGHT IS RIGHT.
IT GIVES THEM PREDICTABILITY, AND IT GIVES THEM PROSPERITY.
AND WE NEED TO FIND BACK TO THAT FUNDAMENTAL VALUES THAT CAME NOT ONLY FROM THE U. N. CHARTER, BUT ALSO FROM THE UNIVERSAL DECLARATION OF HUMAN RIGHTS.
AND I CAN TELL YOU IN MY OWN INTERACTION WAS THE SERVICE THAT WE SEE, THE VAST MAJORITY OF PEOPLE CARE ABOUT THIS.
SO WE HAVE THE MAJORITY OF PEOPLE IN THE WORLD BEHIND US.
>> I MEAN, WE'VE SPOKEN A LOT ABOUT GAZA, AND IT DOESN'T SEEM TO BE ANY SORT OF END IN SIGHT TO THE SUFFERING OF THE PEOPLE THERE, DESPITE THE TRUMP PEACE PLAN, THERE WAS MEANT TO BE RECONSTRUCTION AND EVERYTHING.
BUT IT SEEMS THE ISRAELI GOVERNMENT IS NOT INTERESTED AT THE MOMENT.
BUT YOU CAN COMMENT ON THAT IN A MINUTE.
BUT ALSO WHAT ABOUT ALL THESE REFUGEES OR RATHER DEPORTEES FROM THE UNITED STATES WHO ARE GOING TO PLACES IN AFRICA AND EVEN IN EUROPE THEY'RE BEGINNING TO WANT TO SEND THEM, AGAIN, TO PLACES LIKE RWANDA AND ELSEWHERE?
>> I MEAN, ONE THING THAT IS VERY STRIKING IS THAT WE HAVE A MIGRATION DEBATE BOTH IN EUROPE, BUT ALSO IN THE U. S. THAT IS VERY TOXIC, VERY POLARIZING, DEHUMANIZING, AND IT REALLY HAS TO STOP FROM FACTS, FROM A DEEP APPRECIATION OF WHAT MIGRANTS BRING TO THE WORLD AND THE CONTRIBUTIONS, THE EXTREMELY VALUABLE CONTRIBUTIONS THAT THEY MAKE.
AND WE NEED TO GET OUT OF THIS VERY POLARIZED DEBATE THAT IS TAKING PLACE.
HAVE I HUGE ISSUES WITH EXTERNALIZATION OR EXTRA TERRITORIAL MECHANISMS SUCH AS THE ONE THAT YOU'VE MENTIONED BETWEEN FIVE EU MEMBER STATES AND IRAN, FOR EXAMPLE, BECAUSE IT CONTAINS HUMAN RIGHTS RISKS.
BUT IT'S ALSO WRONG TO SEND PEOPLE TO A OPPORTUNITY WHERE THEY HAVE ABSOLUTELY NO AFFILIATION, NO LINKS.
WE HAVE SEEN THESE PRACTICES IN THE PAST.
THEY NEVER WORKED.
THEY WERE TERRIBLE FOR THE PEOPLE WHO ARE INVOLVED.
BUT THEY ALSO WERE VERY COSTLY FOR TAXPAYERS.
I MEAN, WE NEED TO FIND BACK TO A BASIC SENSE OF HUMANITY AND REASON WHEN IT COMES TO MIGRATION.
IT CAN BE TACKLED.
IT CAN BE TACKLED ON THE BASIS OF EVIDENCE, ON THE BASIS OF FACTS WITHOUT THIS HUGE EMOTIONS AND THE DEHUMANIZATION THAT I OFTEN HEAR IN POLITICAL DEBATES AGAINST MIGRANTS.
IT'S REALLY A TIME TO CHANGE COURSE ON THAT FRONT.
>> VOLKER TURK, SO MUCH TO TALK ABOUT.
THANK YOU SO MUCH.
>> THANK YOU.
> >> NOW U. S. AIR TRAVEL MIGHT BE SLOWLY RETURNING TO NORMAL, BUT QUESTIONS REMAIN OVER WHAT CAUSED THE GROUNDING OF FLIGHTS ACROSS THE COUNTRY.
OUR NEXT GUEST ARGUES THERE IS NO COINCIDENCES WHEN AI IS INVOLVED.
DR.
AYANNA HOWARD HAS SPENT HER CAREER EXPLORING THE REACH AND IMPLICATIONS OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE AND SAYS THAT WE'RE ONLY JUST BEGINNING TO UNDERSTAND HOW DEEPLY EMBEDDED IT IS IN ALL OF OUR LIVES.
FOLLOWING HER APPOINTMENT AS PRESIDENT OF SPELMAN COLLEGE AND THE RELEASE OF A NEW BOOK ON THE MORALITY OF AI, HOWARD JOINS MICHEL MARTIN TO DISCUSS WHY WE MUST QUESTION THE ETHICS OF THIS RAPIDLY EVOLVING TECHNOLOGY.
>> THANKS, CHRISTIANE.
PROFESSOR AYANNA HOWARD, THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR SPEAKING WITH US.
>> THANK YOU FOR HAVING ME.
>> I SHOULD SAY MADAM PRESIDENT HOWARD, BECAUSE IN ADDITION TO YOUR DISTINGUISHED CAREER FROM ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE, TEACHING ROBOTS, NAVIGATING THE SURFACE OF MARS AT NASA, YOU'RE ALSO THE PRESIDENT OF SPELMAN.
>> YES.
EDUCATING AND THINKING ABOUT HOW DO WE CREATE AND BUILD AND ENSURE THIS NEXT GENERATION THRIVE IN THIS UNCERTAIN WORLD WE HAVE IN FRONT OF US.
>> YOU HAVE LITERALLY HUNDREDS OF PUBLICATIONS IN YOUR FIELD.
BUT I THINK THIS MIGHT BE YOUR FIRST BOOK FOR A GENERAL AUDIENCE.
"REBOOTING THE MACHINES: A NEW VISION FOR HUMAN AUDIENCE. "
WHY THIS BOOK NOW?
>> I WAS WORRIED BECAUSE I WAS HEARING THIS NARRATIVE AROUND ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE AND ROBOTICS.
IT'S KIND OF EXTREMES.
AI IS GOING TO DESTROY HUMANITY AND TAKE OVER ALL THE JOBS.
AND I HEAR ROBOTS ARE SO PERFECT AND AI IS SO BEAUTIFUL.
IT'S GOING TO SAVE US ALL.
AND THE REALITY IS THAT IS NOT THE TRUTH.
SO I FELT I HAD A RESPONSIBILITY TO GIVE AND EMPOWER PEOPLE, EVERYONE TO REALLY TAKE CONTROL OF THE NARRATIVE AND UNDERSTAND THEIR OWN POWER SO THAT WE DON'T HAVE ONE EXTREME OR THE OTHER.
>> YOU SAY IN THE BOOK THAT YOU STARTED OUT AS AN --IN FACT YOU REMAIN KIND OF A REALISTIC OPTIMIST, BUT THAT YOUR OWN SKEPTICISM ABOUT IT AND CONCERNS ABOUT ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE HAVE ACTUALLY GROWN OVER TIME.
SO COULD YOU TALK A LITTLE BIT ABOUT THAT.
>> SO I DID NOT EXPECT HOW MUCH AI WOULD BE EMBEDDED IN EVERYTHING, FROM EDUCATION TO HEALTH CARE TO EVEN SOMETHING AS YOU THINK AS SIMPLE AS WHO GETS A LOAN OR NOT OR WHO GETS INTO A HIGH SCHOOL.
SO WHEN WHAT I WORRY ABOUT IS WE ARE NOT REALIZING THAT THIS COULD BE A PROBLEM IF WE ARE NOT ACTIVELY ENGAGING, THINKING ABOUT RULES, REGULATIONS, THE BIAS.
WHAT I FEAR IS I THINK THAT WE HAVE PEOPLE WHO ARE AFRAID SO THEY DON'T ENGAGE.
THEY DON'T USE THEIR VOICE, AND THEN WE HAVE THOSE WHO ARE EMPOWERED.
YEAH, BUT I'M GOING TO TAKE ADVANTAGE OF ALL THESE THINGS.
AND I WORRY THAT WE ARE DISENFRANCHISING BASICALLY A LOT OF OUR WORLD.
SO I FEAR THAT, WHICH IS WHY I NEED TO SPEAK UP.
>> ONE OF THE INTERESTING POINTS THAT YOU MAKE IS THAT ON THE ONE HAND, YOU SAY THAT PEOPLE LOOK AT ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE THE WAY THEY OFTEN LOOK AT IMMIGRANTS, WHICH IS TO SAY WHAT IS THIS THING THAT'S ENCROACHING INTO MY SPACE AND TAKING WHAT SHOULD BE MINE.
ON THE OTHER HAND, YOU SAY PEOPLE OVERTRUST THESE TECHNOLOGIES IN A WAY THAT THEY TREAT THEM LIKE THEY'RE HUMAN WHEN THEY'RE NOT.
THEY HAVE NO MORAL CENTER.
SO IT JUST SEEMS WEIRD THAT WE HAVE THESE CONTRADICTIONS IN US AT THE SAME TIME.
HOW DO YOU UNDERSTAND THAT?
>> WELL, I UNDERSTAND IT BECAUSE WE HAVE CONTRADICTION WAS OUR OTHER SELVES.
SO IF YOU THINK ABOUT A WORLD AND OUR SOCIETY, WE ARE FRIENDS WITH CERTAIN INDIVIDUALS IN OUR NEIGHBORHOOD.
AND A BLOCK LATER, WE WILL BE ENEMIES.
AND YET WE'RE ALL HUMAN.
YOU MIGHT BE THE SAME RACE, THE SAME GENDER, AND YET WE CAN'T AGREE ON CERTAIN THINGS.
AND THE FACT IS AI AND ROBOTICS, IT IS BUILT UPON OUR HUMAN INTERACTIONS.
SO THE FACT THAT WE HAVE THIS COMPLEX RELATIONSHIP WITH AI IS REALLY DRIVEN BECAUSE WE HAVE A COMPLEX RELATIONSHIP WITH OURSELVES.
>> I DO WONDER WHETHER PART OF THIS INSIGHT COMES FROM THE FACT THAT YOU DO NOT COME FROM THE SAME BACKGROUND AS SO MANY OTHER PEOPLE IN YOUR FIELD.
YOU NOTICED EARLY ON THAT THESE ALGORITHMS CAN BE OPPRESSIVE, THAT THEY CAN INTRODUCE THE SAME KINDS OF BIASES THAT HUMANS HAVE.
THAT IS THE KIND OF INSIGHT THAT SEEMS TO BE VERY MUCH MISSING FROM A LOT OF OUR CONVERSATIONS.
ABOUT THIS TECHNOLOGY.
SO I GUESS WHAT I'M SORT OF WONDERING IS WHY IS THERE NOT MORE UNDERSTANDING OF THE WAY THESE THINGS CAN GO AWRY?
>> I WOULD SAY IT'S TWO REASONS, I BELIEVE.
I BELIEVE ONE IS THAT A LOT OF PEOPLE SAY WELL, IT'S NOT HAPPENING TO ME.
AND SO THEY DON'T REALIZE THAT IT CAN HAPPEN.
AND SO IT'S KIND OF THE BYSTANDER OH, IT'S NOT ME.
IT DOESN'T IMPACT MY COMMUNITY.
SO OF COURSE IT'S FINE.
SO THAT'S ONE THING.
UNTIL IT COMES HOME, A LOT OF PEOPLE ARE NOT GOING TO SAY ANYTHING.
THE OTHER IS THAT THE POSITIVE ELEMENTS THAT COME FROM IT, OH, MAYBE I'M OKAY WITH HAVING THE BENEFITS BECAUSE I DON'T ACTUALLY SEE THE NEGATIVES, OR THE NEGATIVES MIGHT BE SO MINOR IN MY EYE.
THE FACT IS, THOUGH, IF WE CONTINUE NOT ADVOCATING, IF WE CONTINUE NOT PUSHING FORWARD AND ASKING FOR THESE THINGS, LIKE LET'S HOLD OURSELVES AS WELL AS OUR COMPANIES, OUR GOVERNMENT ACCOUNTABLE, EVENTUALLY IT WILL COME INTO ALL OUR NEIGHBORHOODS.
IT WILL COME TO OUR SHORES, OR COMMUNITIES AND OUR HOMES.
NOW IS THE TIME TO ACTUALLY TRY TO FIGURE IT OUT.
BECAUSE IT'S ACCELERATING, AND AT SOME POINT, WE WON'T HAVE THE POWER.
>> IT'S INTERESTING.
I THINK THAT SORT OF THE WORM HAS TURNED HERE.
ACCORDING TO A 2026 PEW RESEARCH CENTER SURVEY, 52% OF AMERICANS SAY THEY ARE MORE CONCERNED THAN EXCITED ABOUT AI COMPARED WITH JUST 9% WHO ARE MORE EXCITED THAN CONCERNED.
NOW YOU'VE ALREADY SAID THAT FEAR AND DISENGAGEMENT IS NOT THE ANSWER, BUT DO YOU THINK THAT SOMETHING HAS SHIFTED IN PEOPLE'S CONCERN ABOUT IT?
AND IF SO, WHY DO YOU THEY IS?
>> SO I WOULD SAY IF YOU LOOK AT THE STATISTICS OF CONCERN, IF I GO BACK A DECADE, THERE WAS EVEN MORE CONCERN.
AND SO THERE IS STILL A LOT MORE CONCERN, ESPECIALLY IN THE U. S. , NOT NECESSARILY IN OTHER COUNTRIES.
BUT THE CONCERN IS BECOMING LESS THAN IT WAS A DECADE AGO.
AND YET THE POWER OF AI IS MORE.
SO THAT'S ONE OF THE THINGS.
THE OTHER IS THAT PEOPLE ARE USING AI ALL THE TIME.
AND I THINK THAT THEY DON'T REALIZE HOW THEY'RE USING IT.
SO THERE IS A CHAT BOX.
AND SO YOU CAN SAY OH, I'M NOT GOING TO USE THE CHAT BOX.
BUT IF YOU'RE USING EMAIL, IF YOU'RE USING ANY OF THE WEB CONFERENCES, IF YOU'RE DRIVING A CAR EVEN, AI IS EMBEDDED IN EVERYTHING.
AND YET I DON'T THINK PEOPLE REALIZE THAT OR KNOW THAT.
>> WELL, OBVIOUSLY PEOPLE ARE ALSO CONCERNED ABOUT JOB LOSS.
I MEAN, A RECENT GALLUP SURVEY FOUNTAIN 27% OF AMERICAN WORKERS WORRY THAT TECHNOLOGY COULD MAKE THEIR JOBS OBSOLETE, ROUGHLY DOUBLE THE SHARE IN 2017.
AND YOU SAY THAT'S ABSOLUTELY TRUE.
IT IS GOING TO MAKE SOME JOBS OBSOLETE, JUST LIKE THE INDUSTRIAL REVOLUTION MADE SOME JOBS OBSOLETE AND OTHER SORT OF SEISMIC CHANGES HAVE MADE JOBS OBSOLETE.
IN YOUR VIEW, IT WILL CREATE OTHER JOBS.
BUT THAT IS NOT AN UNREALISTIC CONCERN.
>> IT IS NOT AN UNREALISTIC CONCERN.
AND I WOULD SAY UNLIKE THE INDUSTRIAL REVOLUTION, IT WILL IMPACT EVERY JOB.
I CLEARLY BELIEVE IT IS NOT GOING TO BE ONE CLASS OF JOBS.
IT WILL IMPACT ALL OF OUR JOBS.
THE QUESTION IS WHICH ONES WILL BE ERADICATED, WHICH WILL BE BECOME NEW.
LET'S EDUCATE OUR STUDENTS SO THAT THEY ARE TRAINED FOR WHATEVER JOBS ARE GOING TO COME INTO EXISTENCE THAT DON'T EXIST TODAY.
BUT WE'RE NOT DOING THAT AS A SOCIETY.
WE WILL HAVE AN ENTIRE SWATH OF INDIVIDUALS THAT WILL NOT HAVE JOBS BECAUSE WE AS A SOCIETY, AS A WORLD ARE NOT BEING INTENTION A. M. ABOUT OKAY, LET'S TRAIN THOSE THAT ARE BEING DISENFRANCHISED, THAT ARE BEING REMOVED, THAT ARE BEING LEFT OUT OF THIS WHOLE NARRATIVE AS AI CONTINUES TO TAKE OVER OUR JOBS.
DO.
>> YOU HAVE SOME INSIGHT INTO THE ISSUE THAT'S REALLY TOP OF MIND FOR SO MANY PEOPLE?
THESE DISRUPTIONS IN RECENT DAYS, NATIONWIDE GROUND HALT OF AIRPLANES BECAUSE A TECHNOLOGY PROBLEM WE'RE TOLD, MASSIVE MICROSOFT OUTLOOK OUTAGE, ANOTHER AIRLINE JUST DAYS AFTER THIS NATIONWIDE GROUND HALT, YOU KNOW, AIRLINES HAVING DIFFICULTY TAKING OFF.
DO YOU HAVE ANY INSIGHT INTO HOW THIS HAPPENED?
AND DO YOU THINK BASED ON YOUR EXPERIENCE AT SOME OF THESE INSTITUTION, WHETHER THEY'RE BEING FULLY TRANSPARENT WITH US ABOUT WHAT HAPPENED?
>> I DON'T BELIEVE IN COINCIDENCES.
AND THAT'S JUST MY ENTIRE LIFE.
AND IF YOU LOOK AT THE SIGNS OF HOW OUR NETWORKS ARE BEING BASICALLY ATTACKED, I'M USING THAT WORD INTENTIONALLY, ATTACKED.
THE OTHER ONE WAS NSA.
I BELIEVE THERE WAS SOMETHING AROUND THEIR NETWORKS.
THE FACT IS THIS IS NOT A COINCIDENCE.
AND THE THINGS THAT AI CAN DO ARE THE THINGS THAT BAD PEOPLE CAN DO WITH AI ARE THESE KINDS OF THINGS.
IF YOU HAVE THE TOOLS, THREE HOURS TO GET INTO A SYSTEM, IT'S VERY DIFFICULT FOR US TO ADAPT.
ESPECIALLY GIVEN THAT OUR INFRASTRUCTURE IS PRETTY OLD AND ARCHAIC.
I DO NOT BELIEVE IN COINCIDENCES.
I WISH THAT THERE WAS A NARRATIVE AROUND WHAT IS GOING ON AND HOW WE CAN ENSURE THAT WE CAN PROTECT OURSELVES.
I WORRY THAT WE WILL HAVE A CONVERSATION SIX MONTHS FROM NOW AND IT WILL BE OH, YEAH, THIS IS ALL THE THINGS THAT HAVE HAPPENED THAT WE DID NOT KNOW, AND WILL IT BE TOO LATE AT THAT TIME?
I DON'T KNOW.
AND I DO WORRY ABOUT IT, BECAUSE IT'S DRIVEN I'M PRETTY SURE BY AI TOOLS THAT NEFARIOUS ACTORS ARE USING.
>> YOU REALLY DO BELIEVE THAT THERE IS SOME MAL INTENTION HERE, THESE AREN'T JUST PATCH MISTAKES OR AI GLITCHES THAT HAVE NOT BEEN FORESEEN?
>> I DO NOT.
AND IF YOU THINK ABOUT THE TIMING OF IT WITHIN THIS VERY CONCENTRATED TIME, THE TYPES OF THINGS ARE VERY, VERY SIMILAR IN TERMS OF NETWORKING COMMUNICATIONS.
IT'S --I DON'T BELIEVE IN COINCIDENCES.
>> HMM.
AND DO THESE COMPANIES, THE ENTITIES THAT ARE AT THE CORE OF THESE INCIDENTS, DO THEY HAVE ANY INCENTIVE OR REQUIREMENT TO TELL US THE TRUTH?
>> I THINK THEY DO.
AND I WOULD SAY IF THEY KNEW THE TRUTH.
I ACTUALLY DON'T THINK THAT WE KNOW EXACTLY WHAT'S GOING ON WHICH IS I THINK A LITTLE BIT OF THE FEAR.
IT'S HAPPENING.
I WOULD SAY THAT THE COMPANIES, ONE OF THE THINGS IS THAT THEY ARE IT RATING AND TRYING TO FIGURE IT OUT QUICKLY SO WE CAN GET BACK.
I'M HOPING THAT AT SOME POINT WE HAVE GOVERNMENT AND REGULATORS AND COMPANIES GET TOGETHER TO SAY LOOK, THIS IS AN ALL HANDS ON DECK.
LET'S FIGURE IT OUT.
LET'S SHARE.
MAYBE WE CAN GET AHEAD OF THIS.
>> HMM.
WELL, TO THAT END, YOU PROPOSE CREATING AN INDEPENDENT AGENCY TO OVERSEE ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE.
WHAT WOULD THAT LOOK LIKE?
>> SO I THINK ABOUT IT LIKE WITH THE FDA.
SO WHEN WE THINK ABOUT PHARMA, WE THINK ABOUT DRUGS, THERE ARE SOME VERY STRICT PROTOCOLS IN TERMS OF HOW DO YOU TEST AND ENSURE THAT YOU ARE ENGAGING WITH MULTIPLE INDIVIDUALS, AGES, GENDER, NATIONALITY, RACE, SOCIO-ECONOMICS.
THAT'S A REQUIREMENT.
ONE OF THE THINGS IS WE HAVE TO HAVE A THRESHOLD TO SHOW THAT WE HAVE MORE GOOD, MORE BENEFIT THAN HARM.
ALL DRUGS, THERE ARE SOME HARM OR ELEMENT BUT THE GOOD OUTWEIGHS THE HARMS.
WHEN YOU'RE DEPLYING A DRUG, IF YOU HAVE ANY OTHER FINDINGS, IF SOMETHING HAPPENS, ONE YOU, HAVE TO REPORT IT.
BUT YOU ALSO SOMETIMES TAKE IT OFF THE MARKET.
IMAGINE AI WORKED THE SAME.
AI FOR HEALTH CARE, SINCE WE'RE TALKING ABOUT DRUGS WHERE YOU HAVE AI.
IT'S OUT THERE.
YOU'VE ENGAGED WITH INDIVIDUALS IN THE HOSPITAL ENVIRONMENT.
SO YOU SAY THESE ARE THE BENEFITS.
IT'S BETTER THAN THE HARMS.
AND THEN SOMETHING HAPPENS.
YOU FOUND OUT THAT THE DATA DOESN'T WORK VERY WELL WITH RESPECT TO THE DIAGNOSIS FOR BLACK WOMEN, AS AN EXAMPLE.
WELL, GUESS WHAT, YOU PULL IT OFF THE SHELF, AND NOW YOU'RE GROUNDED.
SO CAN WE DO SOMETHING LIKE THAT WITH ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE.
>> WHAT ABOUT INDIVIDUALS?
BECAUSE ONE OF THE POINTS THAT YOU MAKE IN THE BOOK, WHICH I ALSO FOUND REALLY FASCINATING, IT'S NOT JUST THAT FEAR AND DISENGAGEMENT DON'T WORK.
THE FACT IS THAT THESE TECHNOLOGIES ARE GOING TO PROCEED.
AND YOU SAY IF PEOPLE KIND OF STOP ENGAGING, THEN ALL THE COMPANIES DO IS STOP TALKING TO US.
WHAT SHOULD WE WITH DOING ON AN INDIVIDUAL LEVEL?
>> SO I THINK INDIVIDUALLY THERE IS A NUMBER OF THINGS, AND IT REALLY DEPENDS ON THE APPLICATION.
SO ONE IS QUESTION YOUR TOOLS.
ASK FOR A SECOND OPINION.
MAPPING.
I USE TYPICALLY THREE DIFFERENT TYPE OF APPLICATIONS IN TERMS OF TRYING TO GET FROM A TO ANOTHER POINT.
AND GUESS WHAT?
ALL THREE OF THEM WILL TELL ME A LITTLE SOMETHING DIFFERENT.
OKAY, LIKE NOW LET ME PUT MY INTELLIGENCE TO THINK OF OKAY, WHAT IS IT THAT I VALUE?
DO I WANT A SCENIC ROUTE?
I'M OKAY WITH THE TRAFFIC.
LET'S QUESTION IT.
THE OTHER THING IS THAT WHEN YOU'RE USING IT, YOU CAN CHOOSE NOT TO.
>> HMM.
WHAT ABOUT ON THE POLICY LEVEL?
BECAUSE ONE OF THE WAYS THAT PEOPLE HAVE BEEN EXPRESSING THEIR CONCERN, AND IT'S NOT JUST A METAPHOR.
SOME OF THESE ARE REAL TANGIBLE CONCERNS ABOUT DATA CENTERS, FOR EXAMPLE.
THE NOISE, THE LAND USE, THE IMPACT ON ELECTRICITY BILLS.
AND SO PEOPLE HAVE BEEN ORGANIZING AGAINST THESE DATA CENTERS.
BUT ONCE THEY'VE DONE THAT, IS THERE SOME OTHER SORT OF POLICY ISSUE THAT PEOPLE COULD GET BEHIND THAT WOULD BE A GOOD OUTLET FOR THIS ENERGY THAT WOULD ALLOW AI TO USE THE THINGS THAT IT COULD BE GOOD AT?
>> SO I THINK ALL THINGS AROUND ADVOCACY ARE --WHEN I THINK ABOUT RESPONSIBLE ADVOCACY ARE IMPORTANT.
BUT THE QUESTION IS FIGURING OUT WHAT IT IS THAT YOU WANT AND WHAT IS IT THAT YOU NEED.
SO WHEN YOU THINK ABOUT DATA CENTERS, WE DON'T WANT DATA CENTERS BECAUSE OF THE CONSUMPTION OF THE WATER, CON -- CONSUMPTION OF THE ENERGY.
OUR BILLS DO GO UP IN THAT REGARD.
THERE ARE CENTERS YOU CAN CREATE THAT ARE LOWER ENERGY, USE LESS WATER.
OKAY.
SO IF YOU'RE GOING TO PUT IN A DATA CENTER, MAYBE WE FORCE SOME OF THESE THINGS.
AND IF THE ENERGY BILL GOES UP, LET'S MAKE SURE THAT THE COMPANY IS PART OF THEIR AGREEMENT, AS PART OF THE LICENSING, AS PART OF WHAT THEY'RE GIVEN, THEY HAVE TO ALSO FIX IT.
SO I THINK IT'S A QUESTION OF WHAT IS IT THAT WE ARE ASKING FOR.
IT NO DATA CENTER OR IS IT A RESPONSIBILITY DATA CENTER?
AND IF IT'S NO DATA CENTER, WHAT SOUR RESPONSIBILITY THEN OF NOT USING THE AI?
BECAUSE THE COMPANIES WOULD NOT BUILD THE DATA CENTERS IF WE AS A SOCIETY WERE NOT USING THE AI TOOLS.
SO THINKING ABOUT COMMUNITY ADVOCACY GROUPS VOICING AND CONTRIBUTING AND THINKING WHO IS OUT THERE THAT WHAT IS RESPONSIBLE.
DATA CENTER WHERE?
WE SHOULDN'T PUT IT IN ATLANTA.
MAYBE THAT'S NOT WHERE WE SHOULD PUT IT.
BUT MAYBE WE SHOULDN'T PUT IT IN RURAL SOUTH CAROLINA EITHER.
LET'S HAVE A CONVERSATION AND DECIDE WHAT IT IS THAT WE WANT AND BEING AN ADVOCATE RESPONSIBLY ADVOCATING WITH A RESULT AND A PURPOSE.
>> ANOTHER INTERESTING POINT YOU MAKE IN THE BOOK IS YOU ARE NOT IN FAVOR OF A UNIVERSAL BASIC MINIMUM WAGE, OR UNIVERSAL BASIN INCOME.
WHY?
A LOT OF THE TECH ADVOCATES ARE ADDING THAT BECAUSE THEY KNOW THERE IS GOING TO BE JOB LOSS.
AND THE ARGUMENT IS THAT THIS COULD LEAD TO PEOPLE FLOURISHING IN OTHER WAYS.
BUT YOU'RE NOT A FAN.
WHY IS THAT?
>> SO I DO BELIEVE THAT WE AS A SOCIETY SHOULD PROVIDE SOME BASICS IN TERMS OF HOUSING, IN TERMS OF EDUCATION, IN TERMS OF HEALTH CARE.
SO OUTSIDE OF THAT.
BUT WHEN I THINK ABOUT UVI, I THINK ABOUT THE SAYING "LET THEM EAT CAKE. "
THE FACT IS WHEN YOU ARE PROVIDING A BASIC INCOME, IT ALMOST FEELS LIKE YOU ARE TRYING TO SELL YOUR IDEAS SO THAT PEOPLE WON'T ADVOCATE, PEOPLE WON'T PROTEST.
THAT'S WHAT I WORRY ABOUT.
AND SO IT'S NOT ABOUT PROVIDING THE RESOURCES.
WHAT I SAY CIVIL LIBERTIES, THOSE SHOULD BE FUNDED.
BUT BY GIVING US A FEW DOLLARS, OKAY, MAYBE THAT WILL KEEP THEM QUIET WHILE I MAKE MY TRILLIONS, THAT'S WHAT I WORRY ABOUT.
WHAT IS IT THAT WE NEED AS A SOCIETY AS OUR BASIC RIGHTS?
LET'S PROVIDE THAT, AND THEN LET'S FIGURE OUT MAYBE WE SHOULD TAX COMPANIES IF THEY'RE REPLACING PEOPLE WITH AI.
LET'S TAX THE COMPANIES TO THEN GIVE TO IT THE INDIVIDUAL.
SO IT'S BASICALLY A TAX THAT CAN THEN PROVIDE US OUR SERVICE.
THINKING MORE CREATIVELY AROUND WHAT IT IS WE NEED AS THE JOBS CHANGE AND ARE ERADICATED, FRANKLY.
>> SO SPEAKING OF JOBS CHANGING, YOU YOURSELF HAVE MADE --WELL, NOT EXACTLY A HUGE PIVOT.
YOU'VE BEEN DEAN OF THE ENGINEERING SCHOOL AT OHIO AND FIRST WOMAN TO HAVE THAT POSITION, FOR EXAMPLE.
BUT TO LEAD SPELMAN COLLEGE, A HISTORIC INSTITUTION DEDICATED TO EDUCATING BLACK WOMEN, WHY THAT ROLE AT THIS TIME IN YOUR LIFE?
>> SO THIS IS A MISSION, THIS IS A CALLING.
AND WHAT I REALIZED WAS ALL OF THE UNCERTAINTY IN THE WORLD, ESPECIALLY IN THE UNITED STATES BACK WOMEN ARE THE CANARY IN THE MINES.
THE NUMBER OF BLACK WOMEN UNEMPLOYED OR LEFT OUT OF THE EMPLOYMENT VECTOR HAS BEEN ACCELERATED.
A AND THE FACT IS AS BLACK WOMEN, WE STILL ARE TYPICALLY THE LEADS IN THE HOME WHICH MEANS WE'RE THE LEADS OF THE COMMUNITY.
AND I DO KNOW THE BLACK COMMUNITY ACTUALLY CHANGES THE CULTURE OF THE NATION IN TERMS OF WHAT WE BRING.
AND SO TO EDUCATE THIS NEXT GENERATION OF WOMEN IN A LIBERAL ARTS INSTITUTION TO SHOW THE VALUE OF CREATIVE THINKING, OF ETHICAL THINKING AND JUDGMENT AND OF COURSE SOCIAL JUSTICE MEANS WE WILL CREATE A GROUP OF NEXT GENERATION OF WONDERFUL GRADUATES THAT CAN ACTUALLY CHANGE THE WORLD IN A TIME THAT WE NEED IT TO BE CHANGED.
>> PROFESSOR AYANNA HOWARD, MADAM PRESIDENT OF SPELMAN COLLEGE, THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR SPEAKING WITH ME.
>> THANK YOU.
AND ALSO ALL BOOK PROCEEDS, THEY GO TO SPELMAN SCHOLARSHIPS.
>> GOOD CAUSE.
> >> AND FINALLY, A TALE OF TWO CITIES, WITH ONE EGYPTIAN BAND AND ANOTHER CELEBRATED IN NEW YORK LAST NIGHT.
THE NATIONAL BOOK AWARD FOR NONFICTION WENT TO THE WRITER ABDEL ACKMAN EL GENDI.
HIS BOOK "HUNA" IS ABOUT SIX YEARS AS A PRISONER IN EGYPT.
HE WAS NOT THERE TO ACCEPT THE AWARD BECAUSE THE TRUMP ADMINISTRATION DENIED HIM AN EGYPTIAN.
AND THE LATE PRESIDENT ANWAR SADAT RECEIVED A POSTHUMOUS CONGRESSIONAL GOLD MEDAL IN RECOGNITION OF HIS HISTORIC EFFORTS TOWARDS PEACE IN THE MIDDLE EAST.
HE WAS THE FIRST ARAB LEADER TO SIGN A PEACE DEAL WITH ISRAEL, WHICH WAS BROKERED BY THE U. S. PRESIDENT JIMMY CARTER AT CAMP DAVID IN THE LATE '70s.
SADAT'S SON GAMAL ACCEPTED ON HIS LATE FATHER'S BEHALF.
> >> AND THAT'S IT FOR OUR PROGRAM TONIGHT.
IF YOU WANT TO FIND OUT WHAT'S COMING UP ON THE SHOW EACH NIGHT, SIGN UP FOR OUR NEWSLETTER AT PBS.
ORG/AMANPOUR.
THANK YOU FOR WATCHING AND GOODBYE FROM NEW YORK.
LONDON.
?
?
?
?
?
?
> >> "AMANPOUR & CO. "
IS MADE POSSIBLE BY -- THE ANDERSON FAMILY ENDOWMENT JIM ATTWOOD AND LESLIE WILLIAMS CANDACE KING WEIR CHARLES ROSENBLUM NORMA C. WARNER AND PAUL D. WARNER MONIQUE SCHOEN WARSHAW THE SYLVIA A. AND SIMON B. POYTA PROGRAMING ENDOWMENT TO FIGHT ANTISEMITISM THE STRAUS FAMILY FOUNDATION THE PETER G. PETERSON AND JOAN GANZ COONEY FUND KOO AND PATRICIA YUEN, COMMITTED TO BRIDGING CULTURAL DIFFERENCES IN OUR COMMUNITIES BARBARA HOPE ZUCKERBERG AND BY CONTRIBUTIONS TO YOUR PBS STATION FROM VIEWERS LIKE YOU.
THANK YOU.
“I Don’t Believe in Coincidences:” AI Expert Warns of Recent Tech Outages
Video has Closed Captions
President of Spelman College Ayanna Howard discusses the morality and ethics of AI. (18m)
Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorship
New Episode- News and Public Affairs

Top journalists deliver compelling original analysis of the hour's headlines.

- News and Public Affairs

Today's top journalists discuss Washington's current political events and public affairs.






New Episode


New Episode
Support for PBS provided by:
